For fully insured companies

Another double-digit renewal. And no one can tell you why.

You asked your carrier to explain the increase. You got "trend," "large claims," and a number. Fully insured renewals are built to be hard to question, and every year you pay more for less clarity. That model is not sustainable for a growing company.

Book a Renewal Second Opinion 20 minutes. No cost. No documents needed.
Sample
Group renewal noticeEff. 01/01
Enrolled employees
165
Current annual premium
$2,290,000
Renewal annual premium
$2,715,940
Rate action+18.6%

Basis: medical trend, experience, pooling, plan adjustments.

"Can someone explain this?"
75%

of M.E. Wilson's employee benefits business is self-funded.

#2

in Florida for business written in the largest employee benefits captive in the country.

1920

M.E. Wilson has served Florida employers for more than a century.

Why is our premium going up?

Is your health plan a black box?

You know what you pay. But do you know where the money goes?

The renewal lands weeks before your effective date, when the only levers left are higher deductibles and bigger payroll deductions. Negotiating every year is not a sustainable strategy.

Fully Insured:
One Number

  • Network?
  • Admin?
  • Pooling?
  • Carrier profit?
  • Claims?
Total premium

Self-Funded:
Every Dollar Visible

Network / admin10%
Stop-loss protection20%
Unspent claims stay with you
Illustrative cost allocation. Actual costs vary by group.

With fully insured coverage, you see one number. You don't see what's inside it. Self-funding opens the box. You see every dollar, and the claims dollars you don't spend stay with you.

And in a bad year? Stop-loss insurance caps what you pay on any single large claim and on your total claims for the year. In a captive, that protection is shared with other mid-sized employers, so one bad year does not land on you alone.

Here is what's packed inside a fully insured premium

01

Pooling and risk charges

A charge to cover other employers' large claims. You pay it whether or not you had any.

02

Carrier admin and profit

Federal rules let a large group carrier keep up to 15 cents of every premium dollar for overhead and profit.

03

The money you didn't spend

If your claims come in under projection, that surplus isn't returned to you. Medical loss ratio rebates exist, but they're calculated across the carrier's whole block of business, not your company's own claims.

The cost of staying put

What will fully insured cost you over the next five years?

Enter your own numbers. This is simple math on your premium, not a sales estimate.

Use your own renewal history for the most accurate picture.

Premium in year 5$4,035,762
Total spend over 5 years$16,293,783
Added cost vs. today's premium$4,843,783
Per employee per month, year 5$2,038
See what this could look like self-funded

Before you sign

Five questions to ask your carrier and broker

Ask your carrier

  1. What specific claims drove this increase, and can we see the detail?
  2. How much of our premium is pooling, admin, and carrier margin?
  3. If our claims came in lower than projected last year, where did that money go?

Ask your broker

  1. How many of your clients are self-funded?
  2. Has anyone modeled what our plan would cost self-funded?

What self-funding opens up

Self-funding is more than negotiating a number.

You need a consultant who has done it many times. The structure, the vendors, and the execution decide whether you save money or trade one problem for another. We look at every option, and you choose what fits your company and your people.

Pharmacy carve-out

Move your pharmacy benefit to a transparent pharmacy benefit manager and see what every drug actually costs.

Reference-based pricing, as a choice

Offer a dual option: employees pick a traditional network plan or a plan that pays providers a fair, published benchmark. No one is forced into it.

Stop-loss through the captive

Protection against a bad claims year, shared with other mid-sized employers instead of carried alone.

Your claims data

See what is driving cost, month by month, so you can manage it instead of just paying it.

A broker quotes price. A consultant builds strategy. Our expertise is knowing which vendors fit your company and executing it properly.

Already level funded?

Level funding is self-funding with the carrier still in control.

If your broker looked at self-funding and it "didn't make sense," ask what it was compared to. Then ask these three questions.

How much of last year's surplus came back to you?

Many level-funded plans return only part of it, or only if you renew with them.

What happened to your stop-loss price at renewal?

The carrier sets it, and one large claim can drive it up.

Do you get claim-level data?

It's often limited, which makes your costs hard to manage.

Checking is not switching

Loyalty is good. Checking your options is better.

You can like your broker and still want a second set of eyes. Many fully insured renewals are never compared against a self-funded option. A second opinion costs nothing, and you don't have to change anything to get one.

The Renewal Second Opinion

What happens on the call

Step 1

Book 20 minutes

Tell us about your plan and your last few renewals. No documents needed.

Step 2

We assess fit

Based on your size, renewal history, and goals, we tell you whether self-funding deserves a deeper analysis.

Step 3

You decide the next step

If it's worth a closer look, we securely request your census and renewal and model your options, including your worst case in dollars. If it isn't, we'll say so.

Questions CEOs ask

Before you book

We're level funded with Cigna, and our broker already looked at self-funding. Isn't that the same thing?

Level funding is a carrier's packaged version of self-funding. One fixed monthly payment usually bundles the carrier's own stop-loss, network, and pharmacy. It can be a good first step, but the carrier still controls most of the money: how much of a good year you get back, how your stop-loss is priced at renewal, your pharmacy contract, and how much claims detail you see. When self-funding "didn't make sense," it's worth asking what it was compared to. A captive with independent stop-loss, a transparent pharmacy benefit manager, and your own claims data is a different structure from a carrier's level-funded plan.

Isn't self-funding too risky for a company our size?

That is the right question. A captive pools stop-loss protection with other mid-sized employers, so one bad year does not land on you alone. We show you your worst case in dollars before you decide.

Isn't self-funding more work than fully insured?

Yes, a little. Fully insured is the easy button: one bill, one renewal, and the carrier makes the decisions. Self-funding asks a bit more of you, like reviewing claims reports, deciding on stop-loss each year, and choosing vendors. In exchange, you see where your money goes and keep what you don't spend. Our job is to carry most of that work so it doesn't land on HR.

We like our current broker. Do we have to switch?

No. The call is a second opinion on your renewal. You leave with information, and what you do with it is your decision.

Does changing brokers mean changing our medical coverage?

No. Changing brokers is a one-page broker of record letter to your carrier. Your plan, network, and employees' ID cards stay the same. Coverage only changes if you decide to change it, usually at renewal.

Isn't switching brokers a big project for HR?

Less than most people expect. You sign one letter, and we handle the carrier paperwork, gather the data, and run the analysis. HR's part is a few short meetings.

Do we have to wait until renewal to change brokers?

Usually not. A broker of record change can typically happen any time of year, though some carriers have timing rules close to the renewal date. A move to self-funding is timed to your renewal, which is why starting three to six months early matters.

Will our employees notice a change?

In many cases employees keep a familiar network and ID card experience. We cover what would and would not change for your people on the call.

When should we start?

Three to six months before your renewal date gives you real options. If you renew 4/1 or 7/1, this is your window. If you renew 1/1, a second opinion still helps you understand this renewal and plan the move for next year.

What does the second opinion cost?

Nothing. It is 20 minutes with a consultant who works on self-funded plans every day.

Who you'll talk to

Eric Papp

VP of Employee Benefits Consulting at M.E. Wilson, Tampa. Eric works with Florida employers with 150 to 500 employees who are tired of renewals they can't control.

His work starts with a question most fully insured companies have never been asked: what would your plan cost if you funded it yourself and kept what you didn't spend? Eric is the author of Leadership by Choice (Wiley) and Manage Promises, Not People, spoke at SHRM's 2026 national conference, and is a graduate of the University of Notre Dame.

Our goal is simple

"We work for you, not the carriers."

OfficeM.E. Wilson, Tampa, FL
Eric Papp, employee benefits consultant, Tampa, FL
Eric Papp · Tampa, FL

Get a straight answer

Find out if self-funding deserves a closer look.

Book a 20-minute Renewal Second Opinion. You'll leave knowing whether self-funding is worth analyzing for your company and what the next step would be.

Book my Renewal Second Opinion
  • 20 minutes, by phone
  • No cost and no obligation
  • No documents needed to start

Eric Papp, VP of Employee Benefits Consulting, M.E. Wilson